Whichever billing model costs you more depends entirely on how fast your car actually charges on that plug, not on which model looks cheaper on a price list. Per-minute billing charges for time, so a slow-charging car pays more per kWh than a fast one. Per-kWh billing charges for energy, so charging speed doesn't change the price at all.
Two different things being metered
A per-kWh rate multiplies the electricity you take on by a price per unit: charge 30 kWh at €0.45, and you pay €13.50 whether that took 25 minutes or 55. A per-minute rate multiplies the time you're connected, or actively charging, by a price per minute: it doesn't care whether you took on 10 kWh or 25 in that time.
That difference means the two models only agree on price when a car charges at exactly the power the operator assumed when it set the per-minute rate. Any car that charges faster comes out ahead on a per-minute tariff; any car that charges slower comes out behind.
Working the actual numbers
Take a 50 kW DC charger billed at €0.35 per minute, and two cars plugged in for 30 minutes each. Car A holds close to 50 kW for most of that window and takes on about 25 kWh. Car B, limited by a smaller onboard charger or a cold battery, averages 20 kW and takes on about 10 kWh.
Both cars pay the same €10.50 for their 30 minutes. Car A's effective rate works out to €0.42 per kWh. Car B's works out to €1.05 per kWh, more than double, for the identical time on the identical charger. Put the same two sessions on a flat €0.45-per-kWh tariff instead, and Car A pays €11.25 while Car B pays only €4.50. The billing model didn't just change the total, it flipped which car got the better deal.
The charging curve makes it worse near a full battery
Lithium-ion batteries accept power fastest when they're emptier and taper off as they fill, on every EV, not just slow ones. That tapering means the same car pays a worse effective per-kWh rate on the last stretch of a charge than on the first, under per-minute billing, simply because the charging speed itself has dropped. Stopping a top-up before the taper sets in, often somewhere in the last quarter of the battery, keeps a per-minute session closer to its advertised rate.
What to check before you plug in
Look up or estimate your car's realistic average charging power on the connector type you're using, not its marketing headline figure. If that average sits comfortably above the power the per-minute rate assumes, per-minute billing likely favours you. If it sits below, or if you plan to charge past the point where your battery slows down, a per-kWh rate protects you from paying for time your car can't use productively. goodcharge shows a station's fee breakdown, including any time-based rate, on its own page, so you can check the billing model before you commit to a session.